Consider and discuss the following:

Should D be liable for manslaughter if there is proof that he foresaw any, or just some, of the following, but decided to take that risk anyway? 

A serious risk of death 

A serious risk of serious physical injury 

A serious risk of any physical injury 

Any risk of death 

Any risk of serious physical injury

 Any risk of any physical injury

 If you think just some, which ones would you exclude? 

Go through the list again, this time considering: 

Should D be liable for manslaughter if there is proof that he failed to consider any, or just some, of the risks? 

and 

Should D be liable for manslaughter if there is proof that he was indifferent to any, or just some, of the factors above?